Chris turned 40 at the end of 2025, and I wanted to do something special without throwing a big party that he wouldn’t appreciate. So I gave him what I knew he’d appreciate the most: 40 slices of pizza!

Our thirty-second stop was: Summit Pizza Co
88 S Bear Lake Blvd, Garden City, UT 84028

Restaurant Location and Vibe

This was Chris’s second pizza stop while staying in Bear Lake by himself for a few days for a vendor show at Raspberry Days. It’s another local favorite close to Bear Lake. It’s definitely a touristy place and on the small side.

The Pizza

Chris ordered himself a half cheese and half Hawaiian along with some cheese bread.

Chris wondered if the pizza dough was store-bought rather than made in house, but he thought the cheese itself was very good. The ham and pineapple toppings were okay, but not great, and he felt like something tasted off about the pizza sauce.

The cheese bread was delicious, and Chris loved the garlic sauce they used on it.

The Score

Chris rated the pizza at 6.1, and even almost considered a rating of 5.9.
However, he’d rate the cheesebread at 7.9!

Enjoyed this post? Subscribe below to get new posts by email!

Click here for a complete listing of all 40 pizzas we rated!