Chris turned 40 at the end of 2025, and I wanted to do something special without throwing a big party that he wouldn’t appreciate. So I gave him what I knew he’d appreciate the most: 40 slices of pizza!

Our thirty-third stop was: Gusher Pizza & Sandwich Shoppe
40 Dunraven St, West Yellowstone, MT 59758

Restaurant Location and Vibe

We surprised the kids with a secret trip to Yellowstone right before school started. We had pizza one night of our visit. Gushers is definitely a tourist trap for sure! It’s very conveniently located just a few blocks away from the West Yellowstone entrance to Yellowstone National Park. It’s a nice spot for families to eat dinner together, and the menu is diverse enough to make everyone happy.

The Pizza

We ordered a 16” half cheese half Hawaiian pizza along with some cheese bread. The kids got spaghetti meals without sauce.

The pizza had good crunch, and the sauce was alright. The cheese bread was really good.

Chris actually preferred the cheese pizza to the Hawaiian, which we consider to be a good sign. It means the pizza has solid foundations, the toppings just could be higher quality.

Overall it was good average pizza.

The Score

Chris rated the cheese pizza at 6.8, and gave a rating of 6.1 for the Hawaiian.

Enjoyed this post? Subscribe below to get new posts by email!

Click here for a complete listing of all 40 pizzas we rated!